Case study: When trust in a pastor erodes

TL;DR:
This case study draws on a real letter from a church member concerned about her pastor's leadership. She describes repeated turnover among associate pastors, threats against departing staff, declining attendance, and misleading reports about church growth. She believes the church board and district superintendent have not adequately addressed these concerns. The discussion questions invite readers to consider her options, and the afterword explores seven consequences of deception in leadership.

Your friend Sarah comes to you with a question:

"What is the appropriate thing to do when you've come to feel that your pastor is manipulative and perhaps even deceptive?"

Here is Sarah's story:

"I come from a church in Texas. In just the last four years, our pastor has hired four different associate pastors and then asked each of them to resign. Each time he asked one of them to resign, he told that person that he'd make things very difficult if he or she said anything negative about him. So, until much later, the church had no idea of the real reasons these associates left. We want to evaluate him fairly, but he doesn't cut his associates any slack. So, we're not sure why we should give him the benefit of the doubt.

"He seems to struggle with interpersonal relationships. He has treated the youth group as unimportant and has driven several church members away. One result is that attendance has dropped by 25 percent, from 400 to 300.

"I know that, generally, pastors are overworked and underpaid. I know that many of them bear the weight of unrealistic expectations. However, our pastor too often seems willing to bend the truth to achieve what he considers a worthy goal. For instance, he reports people who transfer in from other churches as 'new Christians.' To me, that's being deceptive. It doesn't give either the local church members or our denominational leaders an accurate picture of what is happening. Those kinds of things have eroded trust in him.

"Although our church continues to decline, the board seems unwilling to take action. Some say they want him gone, but they seem content to simply wait out the situation. Their feeling seems to be: 'It's our church, not his, and eventually, he will leave.'

"Complicating the situation is the fact that the pastor and the district superintendent seem to be close friends. On top of that, our district superintendent seems to see himself primarily as a 'peacemaker' rather than a problem solver. So, when he needs to intervene decisively in a situation, he doesn't demonstrate good intervention skills. Those who've tried to talk to the superintendent about problems related to our pastor have simply been told that this is an issue for the local church board. I understand that the local church board has responsibilities in this situation, but aren't there times when the district superintendent needs to lead?

"Some people in the church seem unaware of the problems. Although our town has only about 35,000 residents, as far as I know, the situation has not become a subject of gossip around town.

"There has to be some point when our congregation must change direction and move on. How do we know if we're at that point? If we are, what do we do now?"


  1. How would you respond to Sarah?
  2. She's not on the church board. What are some possible courses of action she can pursue?
  3. What are the possible benefits and risks of each course of action?
  4. Which course of action might be best?
  5. Which course of action would probably be the worst?

—Howard Culbertson, hculbert@snu.edu

Note: This case study is based on a real letter about actual people and events. The wording has been edited for clarity.

Afterword: 7 Consequences of Deceptive Behavior

When people lose trust in a leader because they believe the leader has been deceptive, several consequences can unfold:

  1. Trust is the foundation of effective leadership. When it's compromised, confidence in the leader's abilities and judgment diminishes. Doubt creeps in, leading to uncertainty about the leader's decisions and direction.
  2. Trust is closely tied to morale. When trust in leadership wanes, morale among group members typically follows suit.
  3. Deceptive behavior breeds skepticism. Group members may start questioning not only the leader's truthfulness and integrity but also the leader's intentions. This skepticism can spread, affecting teamwork and cooperation within the group.
  4. A certain level of trust is necessary for good communication. When trust in the leader diminishes, communication channels become strained or may even break down. Group members may withhold information, avoid sharing ideas, and engage in gossip and speculation instead of open dialogue.
  5. Loyalty is often a fruit of trust. As trust in the leader erodes, so does loyalty to the organization and its goals. Group members may start looking elsewhere or at least withdraw emotionally from the group.
  6. Deceptive leadership can create resistance to proposed changes. Group members may view proposed changes with suspicion, fearing ulterior motives or a hidden agenda on the leader's part. Such resistance can impede progress and innovation within the group.
  7. Trust helps people work through disagreements constructively. Conflicts may arise more frequently and escalate more easily when trust is lacking. Group members may become more confrontational or passive-aggressive in their interactions with each other and with the leader.

Here's the bottom line: When people in a group (such as a church) lose trust in their leader because they believe the leader has been deceptive, it can have far-reaching detrimental effects on the group's dynamics, performance, and fruitfulness. Rebuilding trust can be a challenging and lengthy process. To rebuild trust, a leader must acknowledge mistakes, demonstrate transparency, and restore credibility.

Acrostic: Deceit

D—Distorting the truth for personal gain
E—Eroding trust with every lie
C—Concealing motives behind false words
E—Entangling others in webs of deception
I—Inventing stories to mislead others
T—Twisting reality to serve selfish ends

Like acrostics? Here are more of them.

Share this page:

Share on Facebook Share on X Share on LinkedIn Share on WhatsApp

Related articles