Q&A: What do we believe and teach?

TL;DR:
This Q&A presents a Wesleyan-Holiness approach to theology: affirming biblical authority, emphasizing God's grace and human response, upholding historic Christian doctrines, and bringing thoughtful inquiry together with spiritual devotion. Faith and critical thinking can complement each other. When practiced with humility, careful questioning can deepen our understanding of Scripture, strengthen our trust in Christ, and help us distinguish essential Christian affirmations from personal opinions and interpretations.

Questions and answers about what religion professors teach at a Christian university

"You and many others have heard what I have taught. You should teach the same thing to some people you can trust. Then they will be able to teach it to others." — 2 Timothy 2:2 (International Children's Bible)

Answers by Hal Cauthron and Howard Culbertson

Historical setting: These questions and answers originated during Hal Cauthron's tenure as chair of Southern Nazarene University's School of Theology and Ministry, 1999-2017. References to faculty colleagues, institutional relationships, and teaching experiences reflect that setting. The text has been edited for clarity and readability.

The following questions cover a range of issues, from core Christian theological affirmations to scholarly methods and personal opinions. Each answer should be read and evaluated in light of the particular question being addressed.

— Hal Cauthron, chair of the School of Theology and Ministry, Southern Nazarene University, 1999-2017

Question: "Does God have foreknowledge?"

Cauthron: Scripture points to a "yes" answer. Three New Testament texts (Acts 2:23; Romans 8:29; 11:2) attribute foreknowledge to God. Certain Old Testament texts, such as Isaiah 42:9, present God's claim to announce things before they happen. God's declarations through the prophets are therefore often understood as examples of foreknowledge.

Even so, Scripture does not discuss the nature and extent of God's foreknowledge in detail. H. Orton Wiley observes, "The question of divine foreknowledge has been the occasion of much speculation" (Christian Theology, volume 1, page 355). The Articles of Faith do not include a separate article defining the nature and extent of divine foreknowledge.

We must also recognize that, while we are bound by time and space, God is not bound by His creation in the same way. That makes answering this question more difficult.

Question: "Are the first 11 chapters of Genesis allegory or actual occurrences?"

Cauthron: The biblical text does not present these stories as allegories. A helpful description is "primeval narratives/traditions," the term used in Discovering the Old Testament, page 62, a college-level textbook published by The Foundry.

The textbook explains that these stories concern events preceding humanity's written records and describe the world from which Israel's ancestor Abraham emerged to follow God's call. This description identifies their setting and literary character without resolving every question about how each narrative relates to historical events.

Question: "Are the individuals mentioned in the Old Testament, such as Adam, Eve, Noah, Jonah, Job, David, and Solomon, real people or just allegories for teaching principles?"

Cauthron: Scripture presents these individuals as people within its narratives, rather than simply labeling them as allegorical figures. Archaeological discoveries provide historical context for many biblical accounts and corroborate some people, places, and events. They do not independently establish the historical existence of every individual named in this question.

Questions about particular individuals should be considered in light of the literary form, purpose, and historical context of the biblical texts in which they appear.

Question: "Are there specific prophecies in the Old Testament that only Jesus could and did fulfill?"

Cauthron: Yes. The New Testament presents Jesus as the fulfillment of Old Testament passages in a distinctive and decisive way. Two examples are its application of the Servant of the Lord passage in Isaiah 52:13-53:12 to Jesus (see Matthew 8:17; Luke 22:37; John 12:38; Acts 8:32-33; Romans 10:16; 1 Peter 2:22-25) and its application of the Melchizedek priesthood in Psalm 110:4 to Christ (Hebrews 5:6; 7:17, 21). Other examples could also be cited.

Question: "Was the virgin birth a reality or a myth?"

Cauthron: A reality. This is one of the central affirmations of the Church of the Nazarene, expressed in Article II of the Articles of Faith in the Manual. The article affirms that Jesus Christ is eternally one with the Father, became incarnate by the Holy Spirit, and was born of the Virgin Mary. It confesses Him as both fully divine and fully human.

Read the denomination's Articles of Faith.

Question: "Was Jesus' resurrection a bodily, physical resurrection, or was it a spiritual resurrection only?"

Cauthron: It was bodily. The New Testament's testimony, including the Gospels and 1 Corinthians 15, affirms the reality of Jesus' risen body. Paul's description of a "spiritual body" does not reduce the resurrection to the survival of a disembodied spirit.

Jesus' resurrection was more than the resuscitation of a corpse. The Gospels describe Him appearing among His disciples behind locked doors (John 20:19, 26), being initially unrecognized by some followers (Luke 24:15-16; John 20:14-16), and leaving an empty tomb with the burial cloths remaining inside (John 20:5-7).

As a familiar Christian reflection puts it, the stone was rolled away not to let Jesus out but to let His followers see that He was no longer there. This is an interpretation of the scene rather than an explanation explicitly given in the biblical text.

More on Christ's resurrection | More on 1 Corinthians 15

Question: "What do you believe and teach regarding the doctrine of the Trinity?"

Cauthron: We affirm what Article I of the Nazarene Articles of Faith teaches: There is one eternally existent, infinite God, sovereign over the universe, holy in nature, attributes, and purpose. This one God is Triune in essential being, revealed as Father, Son, and Holy Spirit.

Read the denomination's Articles of Faith.

Question: "Did Jesus actually cast out demons?"

Cauthron: Yes. The Gospels consistently testify that Jesus cast out demons, demonstrating the power of God's kingly rule breaking into the human world.

More on demon possession

Question: "I read some stuff on your site that seems to say that you can lose your salvation even though you have accepted Christ fully and with all of your heart. Is that what you believe?"

Culbertson: From our Wesleyan-Arminian perspective, a saving relationship with God can be deliberately abandoned. Advocates of eternal security understand the relationship between perseverance, saving faith, and apostasy differently. Some, for example, interpret a person's final abandonment of faith as evidence that the person was never truly converted.

Our understanding emphasizes that God's grace enables a real human response. We can receive Christ as Lord and Savior, and we can subsequently choose to turn away from Him. This does not mean that every failure, doubt, or moment of spiritual struggle ends a person's relationship with God.

Adam and Eve's choice in Genesis 3 illustrates the seriousness of human freedom and disobedience. Although their situation before the Fall differs from Christian salvation after the Fall, their story shows that a good relationship with God does not eliminate the possibility of rebellion.

In our Wesleyan-Arminian tradition, salvation is best understood as a relationship with God rather than as a possession that can be misplaced. At the very heart of salvation is a relationship. Relationships can be broken, renounced, or abandoned.

We also take seriously the calls to faithfulness in the letters to the seven churches in Revelation 2-3. We understand these warnings and promises as encouragements to continue trusting and following Christ.

This does not mean that our works earn salvation. Salvation is by grace. God offers us a renewed relationship with Him through Christ's saving work. Enabled by His grace, we can begin that relationship, continue in it, or tragically turn away from it.

Question: "What is the Church of the Nazarene's stand on ecumenism with Roman Catholics?"

Culbertson: In the setting in which these answers were first written, the Church of the Nazarene participated in evangelical interdenominational organizations such as the National Association of Evangelicals, while remaining outside the National Council of Churches and the World Council of Churches. Membership in particular organizations, however, does not by itself describe every form of Christian cooperation or dialogue.

We share historic Christian doctrines affirmed in the ecumenical creeds, including belief in the Triune God and in Jesus Christ as the incarnate Messiah, born of a virgin, whose death atones for our sins.

As Protestants in the Wesleyan-Holiness tradition, we differ from Roman Catholic teaching on important matters, including the relationship between Scripture, church tradition, and teaching authority.

These doctrinal differences do not prevent us from treating Roman Catholics with respect and recognizing beliefs we share as Christians.

Question: "What is your church's view on the use of images, such as statues depicting Christ?"

Culbertson: We reverently follow the Ten Commandments, including their prohibition of idolatry. However, we do not regard every artistic representation of Jesus as an idol. Although some Muslims object to depictions of Jesus, Nazarene educational materials use drawings of biblical characters, including Jesus.

The JESUS film, an artistic portrayal of Christ's life, has also been used extensively in Nazarene evangelistic outreach.

Paintings of Christ, including works by Warner Sallman, can be found in Nazarene settings. Sallman's painting of Christ knocking at a door has been used to illustrate an invitation to respond personally to Jesus.

Nazarene teaching does not endorse the veneration of religious images or statues. Such artwork can serve as an illustration or teaching aid, but worship belongs to God alone.

Question: "How do you pursue the healthy questioning that results in academic excellence without diminishing the value of the humble and childlike faith that results in spiritual excellence?"

Cauthron: First, by explaining to students in our General Education courses that humility of heart and life is essential when reflecting on theological issues. Claiming to have all the answers is arrogance. No one has all the answers.

Second, we should be transparent about our pilgrimage of faith. Students need to see and hear us practice our faith while asking and seeking answers to difficult theological questions.

Third, we should begin where students are, encouraging them to consider the implications of their faith commitments and helping them weigh alternatives and questions.

Throughout this process, we seek to show students that we have faced similar questions, submitted our own faith affirmations to rigorous examination, and found our faith renewed and strengthened through that process.

Question: "Can you diminish the historical legitimacy of any biblical character without also diminishing the theological legitimacy of the lessons that particular character communicates?"

Cauthron: This question appears to assume that historical veracity is the complete measure of truth. It moves from the claim that an event actually happened to the assumption that every truthful story must report an actual event.

Consider how we usually understand Jesus' parables. Must we affirm that He was referring to specific individuals when He spoke about a farmer, a landowner, a woman making bread, a pearl merchant, or a father who divided his possessions? See Matthew 13 and Luke 15.

A parable's theological truth is not diminished when we understand it as an illustrative story rather than as a report of events in a particular person's life. In the parable of the prodigal son, for example, the younger son's request and the father's response challenge expectations and help communicate Jesus' teaching about God as Father.

To return to the question: Denying the historical reality of a particular biblical person or event may, in some cases, undermine theological affirmations associated with that account. However, that is not necessarily true of characters in parables or other illustrative stories. We must attend to the kind of literature we are reading and the claims it makes.

Question: "Is the Bible true and authoritative on all issues it speaks to?"

Cauthron: Yes, understood in light of what Scripture intends to teach and the literary forms through which it teaches. The Bible addresses who God is, what human beings are, how we can be reconciled to God, and how we should worship and live in fellowship with Him.

Article IV of the Nazarene Articles of Faith affirms the plenary inspiration of the 66 books of the Old and New Testaments. It teaches that Scripture inerrantly reveals God's will concerning us in everything necessary to our salvation and that teachings not contained in Scripture are not to be imposed as articles of faith.

What we affirm is that the Bible can be fully trusted to lead us to a saving knowledge of God in Jesus Christ.

When we are converted, we receive the gospel proclaimed from Scripture and experience the Holy Spirit's witness that we are forgiven and reconciled to God. We discover the truth and authority of Scripture as its message brings us to faith in Christ.

More on the authority of Scripture | Read the denomination's Articles of Faith

Questions about biblical truth and authority deserve careful consideration. However, gospel preaching does not require a person to resolve every question about the Bible before responding to Christ. Understanding can deepen as faith matures.

Question: "How can you begin to dissect inspired texts (inspired not only originally but perpetually) as true or untrue without making your own understanding the measure of objective truth?"

Cauthron: The concern is understandable. Readers should not make their own preferences the final measure of biblical truth. At the same time, every reader must interpret Scripture, considering its language, literary forms, historical setting, and message.

The Jesus Seminar, a scholarly project that evaluated sayings and deeds attributed to Jesus, illustrates the controversy that can arise over the assumptions and methods used in biblical study. Its conclusions should not be treated as representing all New Testament scholarship.

The approach we affirm begins with confidence in Scripture and humility about our interpretations. Careful study should help us hear the biblical text more faithfully, while allowing it to challenge our assumptions.

Question: "I've spent 18 years praying God's call and God's glory down on my children. Can I be assured the Southern Nazarene University School of Theology and Ministry will strengthen their immature faith and refuse to undermine the simple confidence they have placed in the Bible stories they learned in Nazarene Sunday schools?"

Cauthron: You can have the same confidence I had when I sent my own children to SNU, where they examined their faith commitments under the guidance of my colleagues. Other faculty members likewise entrusted their children's theological education to their SNU colleagues. I trusted my colleagues and was not disappointed in how they related to my two children.

During my time at SNU, my colleagues and I produced a pamphlet titled "Teaching Theology at SNU" to explain our theological and educational commitments. We shared it with representatives of SNU's primary stakeholders, including Nazarene General Superintendents, and received encouragement for the approach we described.

Read the faculty statement about teaching theology at SNU.

One further observation: As believers, we must grow, mature, and develop. As Paul urged the Corinthians, we need to mature spiritually, moving from milk to solid food (1 Corinthians 3:1-3).

Terminology note: "Holy Ghost" is the wording used for the Third Person of the Trinity in many passages of the King James Version. Older English books and articles may therefore use "Holy Ghost" where most modern English Bible translations use "Holy Spirit."

— Howard Culbertson, hculbert@snu.edu

Afterword: Some thoughts on critical thinking

Is critical thinking compatible with the Christian faith?

Yes. Critical thinking can support Christian faith by helping us examine ideas carefully, recognize weak arguments, and grow in understanding.

What does critical thinking mean? It means analyzing and evaluating information carefully to form a reasoned judgment. It does not mean criticizing or disparaging people. Good critical thinking includes questioning assumptions, recognizing biases, considering evidence, and listening to differing perspectives. Here are six reasons it is compatible with Christianity:

  1. Christianity has a rich intellectual tradition that encourages questioning, exploration, and engagement with differing ideas. Christian thinkers have used logic, reason, and careful analysis to understand Scripture, theology, and the world.
  2. The Bible encourages wisdom and sound judgment. Proverbs 3:13 says, "Blessed are those who find wisdom, those who gain understanding" (NIV). In a passage about prophecy, Paul writes, "but test them all; hold on to what is good" (1 Thessalonians 5:21, NIV). That instruction also offers a useful principle for evaluating claims carefully.
  3. Careful questioning can deepen our understanding of faith. Seeking understanding allows faith and reason to work together.
  4. Christian theology involves thoughtful reflection on God's nature, Scripture's message, and the implications of faith for life. Critical thinking helps us examine complex theological ideas and engage respectfully with people who understand them differently.
  5. Critical thinking contributes to ethical decision-making. As followers of Christ, we need to assess moral questions carefully and apply biblical principles to real situations.
  6. Dialogue with fellow believers and people of other faiths or worldviews calls for careful listening and evaluation. Such conversations can help us understand both their beliefs and our own more clearly.

Critical thinking can raise difficult questions about Christian faith. Christians seeking truth can approach those questions as opportunities for growth rather than automatically treating them as threats. God is the ultimate source of truth. Therefore, honest inquiry practiced with humility can deepen our understanding, strengthen our faith, and enrich our relationship with Him.

Share this page:

Share on Facebook Share on X Share on LinkedIn Share on WhatsApp

Related article

You might also like these